Wednesday - Chapter Five Mishnah 4

« July 2008  
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
4
5
9
11
12
18
19
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31

R’ Chaim Sanzer once stopped a Yid as he passed by his house. He asked him, “If you found a chest full of silver and knew to whom it belonged, would you return it?

“Yes,” said the Yid, “I would return the lost item immediately.”

R’ Chaim said, “Are you a fool?”

A second Yid passed by, and R’ Chaim asked him the same question.

The Yid replied, “Do you take me for a fool? You think I would return such a treasure?”

R’ Chaim said, “You’re a rasha.”

R’ Chaim then called out to a third Yid who was passing by and repeated the question.

The Yid responded, “Only when I find the treasure will I know what I would do. It’s possible I will get the better of my yetzer hora for money. But it is also possible that I will not be able to defeat the yetzer hora. Perhaps Hashem will help me withstand the nisayon and I will return the treasure to its owner. But as long as I have not experienced that particular nisayon, I personally do not know what I would do in such a situation.”

R’ Chaim said, “Your teshuvah is the correct halacha. You’re a chacham.”

Rabbi Dovid Goldwasser Pirkei Avos Chapter 5 Mishnah 4d